AddThis SmartLayers

YEP slams abuse of journalists over story of boy on hospital floor

The regional daily which broke the story of a four-year-old boy found sleeping on a hospital floor has run a front page plea urging readers not to be “fooled by fake news” about the incident.

The Yorkshire Evening Post splashed today on an editorial responding to criticism it has received about its exclusive on the plight of Jack Williment-Barr, who was photographed sleeping on the floor of Leeds General Infirmary with suspected pneumonia due to bed shortages.

The hospital itself admitted there was no bed and has apologised, yet YEP editor Laura Collins says her reporters have since “come under attack from trolls and bots on social media channels purporting the story to be ‘fake news'”.

The Leeds-based daily included some examples of those doubting the veracity of its story on this morning’s front page, pictured.

Fake Nws

In her editorial, Laura wrote: “Never has there been a time when journalism, the industry and our journalists have come under such scrutiny and criticism and frankly, it is worrying about the power of social media and its reach. The level of abuse would not be accepted on the streets and must not be tolerated.

“Statistics from YouGov show that local press in print and digital is the most trusted source for local news and information (74.1 per cent). This contrasts starkly with the 22 per cent who trust what is published on social media. This figure should and must speak for itself.

“Our team of reporters will fact-check and verify information at the highest level before it is published – yet anyone can hide behind the guise of a fake profile and tweet out spurious claims without a single check. We will be accountable – nobody will take accountability from a fake account.”

The story by reporter Dan Sheridan was followed up by the Daily Mirror and came to dominate Monday’s general election exchanges, but there were claims on social media that the story amounted to “fake news” and that the picture of Jack was “set up” by his mother and Labour-supporting hospital staff.

HTFP covered yesterday how James Mitchinson, editorial director of YEP owner JPIMedia in Yorkshire, had written a detailed response to one reader who had been taken in by what he called “cynical social media messaging driven by dark forces”.

In her editorial, Laura added: “It is alarming to see that this story of four-year-old Jack is now being used as a political football to score points against politicians as the election campaign enters its final 24 hours.

“However, the fear is now that with all the outcry on social media will this now put people off from coming forward in the future to share their experiences of the NHS whether they are good, bad or indifferent?

“If you’re going to be vilified by strangers questioning your honesty, integrity and care and love for your child then who will ever want to speak out in support of the NHS staff and against its management?

“That will be the real tragedy given that it is stories, such as this, which are integral to shaping the future of the NHS for the benefit of all – young and old alike.”


You can follow all replies to this entry through the comments feed.
  • December 11, 2019 at 1:19 pm

    It’s really heartening to see a title such as the Yorkshire Evening Post still behaving like a regional national, as it were. Closer to home my local daily has largely given up on informed political reporting; however there was a video of the best mince pies available, so I suppose that’s all right then!

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(30)
  • December 11, 2019 at 1:36 pm

    Contrast this paper’s valiant efforts to check and double-check that the story was true before publishing with the likes of Kuenssburg and Peston repeating a single Tory ‘source’ claiming an activist had been punched at a hospital (which turned out not to be true) without verifying it. I know who the decent journalists are here.

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(23)
  • December 12, 2019 at 11:45 am

    Still many unanswered questions about this, however, after today, it will become history. Just checked the latest ABC for the YEP, less than 9,000 copies a day. Very sad demise for a once mighty title and for how much longer will it be allowed to use the word Evening in its title?

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(5)
  • December 12, 2019 at 12:02 pm

    I missed the mince pie video @OneTimeSub as I was reading about the ICYMI “Huge crowds at opening of new Primark store” posts repeated ad nauseous throughout the day which, to be fair, made a pleasant change from the over promotion of trying to flog football collector cards on all digital and print platforms.

    Well done YEP on showing there’s still real local journalism and investigative journalists out there

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(14)