AddThis SmartLayers

Newsroom diversity initiatives ‘must not be box ticking exercise’

Aasma DayRecruitment initiatives which aim to increase newsroom diversity must not become a “box ticking exercise”, editors have been warned.

Industry chiefs were discussing the issue of how to make newsrooms more representative of their communities at an industry conference held in Leicester yesterday.

While there was a broad consensus that more diverse newsrooms would help generate a wider range of stories, speakers warned against “positive discrimination” and “quotas.”

The discussion centred on the ongoing recruitment of 82 new community journalists as part of a Facebook-funded scheme to help increase coverage in under-reported communities.

In a panel discussion, award-winning journalist Aasma Day, pictured, who left the regional press after 20 years to become HuffPost UK’s North of England correspondent in 2018, was quizzed on what could be done to get people from more diverse backgrounds applying for the roles.

Aasma told the conference, hosted by website Behind Local News: “Any scheme that can be launched to encourage people from diverse backgrounds should be positively encouraged, but it’s important it doesn’t turn into a box ticking exercise.

“I would hate to think I’d only got a job because somebody had a quota. I’d hate to feel I only got a job because I was the only brown person that applied.

“People should be given the job on merit and the best person should get the job, otherwise it undermines people’s talent. It’s about being more open-minded in what we want, but still getting the best person for the job.”

Aasma also touched on whether “barriers” needed breaking down within some communities to encourage careers in journalism.

She said: “It’s a shame if there are people out there who express an interest in that and get rejected.”

Chris Page, who works with JPIMedia apprentices in Yorkshire and has around 40 years of experience in the industry, added: “In that time I’ve worked with two people from different races and religions.

“They’re both very proud to represent their communities, but it’s very key that this scheme is pro-active, and not positive discrimination or a box ticking exercise.”

One comment

You can follow all replies to this entry through the comments feed.
  • February 1, 2019 at 12:39 pm

    A big issue for me which never gets addressed is class diversity.

    At the BBC for example they go to great lengths (understandably) to ensure there’s gender and racial diversity, but because of the nature of the beast (only rich kids can afford to intern or do short term contracts) they’re all middle class.

    It’s got huge ramifications for the country. The people reporting on our ‘political class’ are usually from the same background. They equate poverty with whether or not someone can afford a ‘wide screen TV’ and equate things such as immigration concerns with ‘being thick and racist’.

    When TV news crews come to council estates they resemble kids at the zoo. I’ve been on jobs where there’s been a BBC crew and they’ve actually had their own security guards with them.

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(18)