A care leaver has been cleared of trying to break into a weekly newspaper crime reporter’s garden shed, after telling a jury that he was the victim of mistaken identity.
Ryan Chapman, aged 19, who is still receiving support from social workers, was found not guilty by a jury at Exeter Crown Court of trying to burgle local journalist David Shepherd.
The Mid-Devon Gazette reporter spotted an intruder in his garden while he was at home in Tiverton on his day off, and told a jury he recognized him from crime stories he had written in the paper.
He told the jury he was “150 per cent certain” it was Chapman even though he had a clear view of his face for only a second.
He said he knew him from crime stories he has written about him and pictures of prolific offenders he had seen while visiting his local police station.
Chapman, aged 19, of South View, Tiverton, denied attempted burglary and was acquitted despite the jury have been told he had two previous convictions for burglaries in Tiverton, both dating from 2012.
During the two day case Mr Shepherd said he was at his home in Irene Way, Tiverton in the late morning of September 19 last year playing Grand Theft Auto when he spotted movement in his garden.
He said Chapman was wearing a hoodie but he recognized him immediately as he turned and fled. He gave chase and shouted to him that he knew his name but called the police when he lost him.
Chapman said he had not been anywhere near Irene Close on the day of the alleged offence and had probably been with his girlfriend or other friends in the centre of Tiverton.
He said he had never been into Mr Shepherd’s garden or tried to break into his shed, and that it must be a case of mistake identity.
Mr Tom Bradnock urged the jury to acquit on the basis that Mr Shepherd’s view of the intruder had been brief and fleeting, and it was easy to make an honest mistake from such a short glance.
Absolutely no idea what a care leaver might be, but deeply dispiriting to see a journalist suggest they are 150% sure about anything.
He must surely be a relative of Ron – 110% – Atkinson.
Report this comment
One might call Mr Shepherd an expert witness given that he had seen the face of the alleged offender many times.
But, hey ho, it clearly wasn’t him. Well done justice.
ps Loving the GTA reference
Report this comment
Is this Viz or HTFP?
Report this comment
Cracking story of the type readers will love. I particularly like the detail about the victim being a crime reporter and playing Grand Theft Auto when he saw the intruder in his garden. You couldn’t make it up!
Report this comment
Teenager found guilty of breaking into crime reporter’s head
Report this comment
Sept 19 was also a Thursday..was this taken as a lieu day, annual leave or a duvet day…we have to know!!
Report this comment