AddThis SmartLayers

Rapist named after paper overturns reporting gag

A judge’s order banning a self-confessed rapist from being identified has been lifted after representations from a Yorkshire weekly newspaper editor.

Rotherham Advertiser editor Doug Melloy made the complaint in the case of Jack Rees, who had pleaded guilty to rape and sexual assault.

Although the newspaper had previously identified Rees in a report following an earlier hearing, an order by Judge Jacqueline Davies at Sheffield Crown Court imposed anonymity for him and his victim after he admitted the offences on the day of his trial.

But after a letter from the newspaper, Judge Simon Lawler this week amended the ruling, allowing the defendant to be identified but not the victim.

In his letter Mr Melloy said: “Serious sexual offences are a matter of significant public interest and it is well understood that offenders should be dealt with as openly as possible.

“Judge Davies’ decision was unusual, as normally an order is issued to prevent anything being published which could identify the victim and in some cases witnesses.

“It allows the defendant to be named, but the complainant is neither identified nor the relationship to the defendant revealed, in line with industry guidelines agreed with the courts and the Press Complaints Commission’s Editors’ Code.

“The guidelines are to avoid ‘jigsaw’ identification in reports by more than one newspaper or broadcaster.

“In this case earlier reporting by the Rotherham Advertiser without restrictions had allowed the defendant to be named, making his identity a matter of public record.

“As his name is already in the public domain an anonymity order at this stage makes it virtually impossible to report the outcome of the case without causing ‘jigsaw’ identification and is in conflict with the public interest.”