AddThis SmartLayers

Newspaper ’empty chairs’ minister with mock apology to readers

A regional daily has printed a mock apology surrounded by white space after a government minister refused to comment on a story.

The Argus, Brighton, decided to use page five of Saturday’s edition to ’empty chair’ Transport Secretary Chris Grayling after he turned down the newspaper’s request for an interview about rail strikes taking place this week.

Thousands of trains have been cancelled as a result of the five-day strike by Southern Rail staff affecting services across the paper’s patch.

The action by the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers centres over a row about plans for drivers to operate carriage doors rather than conductors.

The mock apology was printed as part of a double-page spread on the strikes

The mock apology was printed as part of a double-page spread on the strikes

The mock apology was carried as part of a two-page spread on the dispute published in Saturday’s edition of the paper.

It reads: “It had been our intention to use this page to carry the Government’s response to next week’s all-out train strike. We had cleared the page for Transport Secretary Chris Grayling to give the tens of thousands of rail users details of the actions he will take to relieve their daily misery.

“We hoped to be able to bring you news that the Government was taking our plight seriously, that it understood the serious concerns for the economy of Sussex and that it was working tirelessly behind the scenes to bring about an end to the appalling train service we are currently experiencing.

“We regret to announce that due to circumstances beyond our control we are unable to offer you this service. Those of you who use the trains regularly will be familiar with the feeling.”

Editor Mike Gilson told HTFP: “We have been covering the deterioration of our train services for the last two years and have held all sides to task.

“In the last few months we have asked the government repeatedly for answers on its role in this scandal which has caused untold misery and have failed to get satisfactory answers.

“Last week ahead of the week-long strike we asked the new Transport Secretary Chris Grayling for an interview so he could tell our readers what the government was doing to help bring an end to this dispute.

“We were not surprised to get a negative response and so decided we would let our readers know this by way of an apology. To me a page of white space and an apology in the place where the Government’s explanation should have been was just about the most powerful statement we could have made.”

The Department for Transport has previously declined requests by The Argus for interviews on rail-related issues in Sussex, after the paper revealed the 7.29am Brighton to London Victoria service had been late every day for a year.

As well as holding Southern Rail and the RMT to account, The Argus has asked the government to explain its role in both the awarding of the contract to GTR, Southern’s parent company, and what steps it is taking to help commuters.

Last month after being rebuffed a number of times reporter Ben James travelled to Westminster armed with a picture of the then Rail Minister Claire Perry to try to get an interview.

After asking members of the public outside the Department if they knew the whereabouts of the woman in the picture he was eventually granted an interview.

5 comments

You can follow all replies to this entry through the comments feed.
  • August 9, 2016 at 11:35 am
    Permalink

    Probably seemed like a good gimmick in the afternoon news conference.
    In reality it just shows how irrelevant the Argus has become – why would a Government grandee want to spend time talking to a newspaper selling barely 12,000 copies a day?
    And why would a declining newspaper want to emphasise its inability to score an interview?
    And as for not giving the remaining readers values for money… they don’t pay for white space, but might expects some words and pictures.

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(8)
  • August 9, 2016 at 2:47 pm
    Permalink

    I think it works too. As any musician would appreciate, it is also the silences in a piece of music that enhances the work. That white space speaks volumes.

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(1)
  • August 9, 2016 at 3:20 pm
    Permalink

    What percentage of Argus readers use the trains? I’m guessing 2-5%, equal to 250-600 readers, the rest couldn’t care less.
    Who cares if a minister doesn’t give a quote? 100% of the readers.

    The actual story of this strike was that only 393 members out of nearly 80,000 voted. The ballot was in April, before the new law was brought in to stop so few people voting to strike. Now at least 50 per cent of union members have to vote, action needs to be supported by 40 per cent of all members. That amounts to an 80 per cent vote in favour of strikes. (source Daily Telegraph)

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(1)
  • August 9, 2016 at 5:04 pm
    Permalink

    Dave, I imagine the number of train users will be far higher than you suggest with London commuters. But that’s not the point.
    Readers should be bothered that the minister isn’t willing to explain the government’s position.
    You’re right about ‘the actual story’ but no doubt the Argus covered that in their spread.
    There’s room to explain the situation and make a point – which they do!

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(1)