AddThis SmartLayers

Dyson at Large: Strong start to thin daily

The choice of splash in the Paisley Daily Express on Saturday 1 March was spot on: ‘Crazed dog to be destroyed’.

This dramatic, impressively detailed court story would have attracted readers of all ages – pet lovers and haters – who wanted to discover the fate of Reggie the boxer, whose mauling of a woman and Ralph, her toy Shih Tzu dog, had previously been reported by the Express.

We all know how popular pet stories are, and those that involve out-of-control dogs and death sentences tend to go viral.

This combination of what sounded like a horrible attack, and the Sheriff’s final condemnation after Reggie’s owner refused to pay for training and misbehaviour classes, made a fascinating read.

Another splash contender was ‘Knife thug slashes man’, which was arguably more newsworthy, but such crimes are so ubiquitous that I think the news desk made the right call to place it on page five.

A local sunset picture from a reader took up half of page two, and felt a little incongruous with foreign news down page, albeit they had grabbing headlines: the lead was ‘A man walks into a bar… with a tiger’, and a stick was ‘You’ve goat to be joking’, about bestiality in Nigeria.

‘Gordon really did a quickstep’ led page three, a bit of a convoluted story about a local teacher’s breathless lesson with Strictly Come Dancing star Kristina Rihanoff.

‘Thanks for your support’ led page four, a decent enough tale about local whisky distillery workers who’d raised £7,000 for local charity – but the headline was a little uninspiring, as was the cheque picture.

The remaining news leads were: ‘Rail passenger boost for Paisley’ on page seven; ‘Chamber boss tipped for top director award’ on page eight; and ‘New firms do the business in Paisley’ on page nine.

And that was about it – a total of 20 news stories on eight traditional news pages, which for me seemed to be too little, spread too thinly.

There was a ‘Paisley’s past’ section of news archives on page six, which are always worth a read; a ‘Church News’ UGC round-up on page 10; and six more readers’ pictures of flowers, nature and traffic filling a spread on pages 12 and 13 (note there were no humans or animals in these pictures).

But in a main book of 24 pages that only contained 63 stories on 20 editorial pages (including two features, two TV and four sports pages), I think the story count per page should have been higher, and that two-and-a-half pages of readers’ pictures was stretching it.

A 16-page ‘Saturday Extra’ pull-out almost came to the rescue – except that this was entirely made up of group features produced in Liverpool for all Trinity Mirror titles.

There’s nothing wrong with a few generic features on film stars, food and drink, fashion, books, travel, gardening and gadgets, and the central features unit produces some quality; but when this non-local copy and pictures make up 40pc of an edition you start to wonder if readers will feel short-changed.

Talking of which, despite its pagination, the ‘wee Express’ (apparently this is how it’s known locally) is pretty good value for money: its sales were boosted when its cover price fell from 45p to 20p in the summer of 2012, and although there have been price rises since it’s still only 40p a day – low compared to most regional dailies.

Until recently, the paper was often applauded for its popularity in Paisley, with sales slowly rising from 10,768 in 1999 to 11,228 in 2005 – not bad for a daily serving a town smaller than Redditch, and one that exists so close to Glasgow and its Evening Times.

The recession, editorial cut-backs and online surges mean sales have dropped off since 2005 like they have for many regionals, but it’s at a slower pace in Paisley: the last ABC figures were 6,767 for the second half of 2013, a -6.4pc fall year-on-year, and -39pc drop over eight years.

Yes, both figures are sobering, but they are below the average trend declines for many regional dailies; it will be interesting, however, to see how long Paisley can afford to remain a daily once those sales drop below 6,000.

Then again, this is a paper that’s always existed on low overheads, and if the news room really does only contain an editor (John Hutcheson), news editor and eight reporters – as listed on page two – then it’s doing a fine job to fill the paper six days a week.

Let’s just hope that Jonathan Russell’s new role as publishing director for Trinity Mirror’s regional titles in Scotland means that the ‘wee Express’ – which he once edited – won’t be overlooked for a little more pagination and resource, or be made to feel too homogeneous, or else the readers will quickly decide its future.

One comment

You can follow all replies to this entry through the comments feed.
  • March 19, 2014 at 12:18 pm

    I’m sure many people will leap to criticise – but to my mind that’s a great-looking front page. Nice and busy and even a few words from the lead story inviting you to turn inside.

    Report this comment

    Like this comment(0)