Steve Dyson's Blog
follow journalism_news at http://twitter.com



Alphason TV Stands from Go Electrical

Classic Car Insurance from Footman James

Pub Insurance from Supercover Ltd

Home Lighting from Light My Home

Wireless Headsets from Headsets4Business

Liebherr Wine Coolers from Go Electrical



rss feed
As featured on News Now
HTFP Facebook page
Email
Journalism books
 

Summer NCE: What the examiners said

Sloppy shorthand and "fictitious" quotes were two of the problems flagged up by examiners in this summer's NCE exam.

Of the 199 hopefuls, 95 passed all four sections – news interview, news report, newspaper practice and logbook – to become senior reporters.

  • Click through to read the main news story and see the list of successful trainees.
  • See here who won the four NCE Awards.
  • Here's our at-a-glance guide to each section of the test, and what the examiners thought of the entries.

    News interview

    Candidates: 151
    Passed: 95
    Pass rate: 63pc

    The test centred around an unprovoked attack on a pensioner in her own home and the aim was for candidates to conduct a face-to-face interview and elicit enough information to write a vigorous and well-balanced story.

    The senior examiner for the news interview said: "The best stories drew a vivid picture in the minds of the readers and supported the opening with an appropriate structure and quotes.

    "Those who did not pass should take note of the skills needed by a reporter in a 21st century newsroom. Publishers quite rightly have a focus on changing technology but core journalistic skills must not be forgotten. It does not matter what platform is being used to tell a story, the basics must still be there.

    "In today's crowded market where there are so many news outlets, it is important to get the best story, the story that will make your publication stand out and be the first that readers will trust."

    News report

    Candidates: 186
    Passed: 98
    Pass rate: 53pc

    Information about the development of a derelict canal basin as a centre for tourism and leisure was given to candidates in a press conference setting.

    The senior examiner said: "Most candidates picked up on the key aspects of the story – the restoration, moorings, homes and opportunities for businesses to set up in the canal basin. Many of the stories submitted were sound, accurate reports from candidates who were a credit to their editors."

    She added: "It was clear that many candidates found their shorthand lacking. The examiners were presented with many partial quote extracts, stitched quotes and even in a few cases completely fictitious quotes.

    "The examiners cannot stress enough just how important it is for a journalist to maintain their shorthand at a minimum of 100wpm throughout their career."

    Newspaper practice

    Candidates: 149
    Passed: 98
    Pass rate: 66pc

    The chief examiner said: "Examiners found some very good answers, but also a relatively high number where candidates had struggled. The practice questions are about ideas and showing how you would tackle a story."

    He added: "Anecdotally we hear that reporters are increasingly tied to their desks and unable to get out to cover stories. If this is the case it may be that they are not amassing enough experience to do themselves justice on the practice questions."

    Logbook

    Candidates: 101
    Passed: 97
    Pass rate: 96pc

    The senior examiner for logbooks said: "The vast majority of logbooks showed solid, well-written copy from journalists who are responding to training and growing in both confidence and stature.

    "One negative trend is that on some occasions poorly written copy is going straight into print or on the website. It appears that some stories do not look to have been edited properly and while this may reflect poorly on candidates, it is an issue for the industry itself to deal with in these difficult times."





    shock_jock (17/08/2009 14:29)
    Just how out of touch are the NCTJ? Having less than half of you students pass your exam is not some kind of badge of honour. It's a reflection of an exam that has very little relevance to the job of youngs journalist today.


    Hack (17/08/2009 15:53)
    Agreed Shock Jock - but that's the point isn't it? An examiner's report and re-take for each failure is more cash in the pot. Using shorthand to cover an intensive, legally-sensitive court case is one thing - sitting in mock conditions while an examiner pretends to be a concerned community leader is another. As a barometer of today's reporters' skills it's worthless. Think £££s.


    poor_hack (17/08/2009 16:48)
    It's funny as journalists we are increasingly asked to do more with less resources yet the NCTJ insist on a senior qualification that is not representitive of the job today. Even the senior examiner reveals that he hasn't stepped inside a local newspaper office for a while: "Anecdotally we hear that reporters are increasingly tied to their desks and unable to get out to cover stories," he says. Well give that man a gold star!


    nomie44 (18/08/2009 12:00)
    I left local newspapers 13 years ago and even back then we weren't allowed out in case we amassed any expenses. Being asked to phone up a mother whose son had just been murdered to save a few quid on actually speaking to her face to face was pretty much the last straw. So maybe the NCTJ should be testing phone and email interview technique now and catch up with the 21st century


    E-mail this story to a friend. Your name:

    Your friend's e-mail:


    tradeclips Jobsmake the next move in your journalism career Email bulletinsget latest news and jobs directly to your desktop Freelance indexsee our searchable list for freelance help CVadd your details to our journalism talent pool Dailywho owns it? who's the editor? Weeklysearch our vast database of local titles Your Paperwhat we've written about your newspaper Your Companywhat we've written about your company Blogsbest of the UK journalism blogs Resourcescontacts, web reviews, and terms unravelled Useful Linksour guide to the major industry organisations