follow journalism_news at http://twitter.com



Alphason TV Stands from Go Electrical

Classic Car Insurance from Footman James

Pub Insurance from Supercover Ltd

Home Lighting from Light My Home

Wireless Headsets from Headsets4Business



rss feed
As featured on News Now
HTFP Facebook page
Email
Journalism books
 

Row erupts over far-right group's newspaper ads

A row has erupted after a number of local newspapers owned by the Newsquest group decided to accept online advertising from the British National Party.

The far-right party is paying for a series of banner ads on the papers' companion websites in the run-up to next month's elections to the European Parliament.

Titles where the adverts appeared included the Stourbridge News, Bromsgrove Advertiser, and Basildon-based daily The Echo.

But Newsquest managers have defended the decision to accept the ads, saying it would be wrong to "selectively discriminate" against political parties in the run-up to an election.

Criticism of the company has surfaced on a number of left-wing blogs, while the National Union of Journalists has also hit out at the move.

General secretary Jeremy Dear said: "Newsquest should be ashamed of itself for taking money from an organisation that advocates racist policies that would directly discriminate against the communities these websites serve."

"Many journalists who have investigated the party in the past have since found themselves on far-right hate websites that try to intimidate journalists to stop them from taking up investigations.

"Journalists covering the elections should also remind themselves of the NUJ's guidelines on reporting racist organisations which are available on the union's website."

Barry Kade, writing on an anti-fascist blog entitled Lancaster Unity, said the ads made the websites "look like BNP publications."

"Many people will be shocked when they look at the online version of their local newspaper. Instead of appearing to serve the whole local community, these newspapers will suddenly take on the appearance of exclusive party political organs - and not just of any party, but of the notorious racist and fascist BNP," he wrote.

Mr Kade claimed the ads "make local newspaper websites look like a BNP publication, with the slogans of the extreme right-wing party dominating the page."

  • The BNP ad as it appeared on the Bromsgrove Advertiser website. The ad is no longer visible.
  • Newsquest Stourbridge has issued a statement in response to a number of complaints from councillors, church groups and others over the ads.

    "We accept advertisements that comply with the law and the Code of Advertising Practice. We cannot selectively discriminate against legally constituted political parties standing in a public election," it said.

    "Indeed, we would say that, in doing so, we might be playing into the hands of those intolerant and anti-democratic forces that people condemn. It is for the electorate to cast judgment, not us."

    Newsquest's head office has also been approached for a formal comment but the company has yet to respond.

    Martin McNeil, editorial director of Newsquest Essex which publishes The Echo, was emailed by a reader concerning the ads. His reply has since been posted on the Lancaster Unity blog by the reader concerned.

    It read: "I appreciate how strongly many people feel about the BNP, but it would be undemocratic and against the principle of free speech to refuse to accept any party's advertising provided it falls within our guidelines.

    "The Echo has consistently opposed the BNP in our Comment column and will continue to do so. As editor, I have twice been taken to court, unsuccessfully, by a BNP activist who did not like my editorial stance.

    "Despite this, I feel I must defend the right of all parties to take out paid-for advertising in support of their election candidates."


    Please complete all the fields below:

    Your name:


    Your email address:


    Comment:


    Please enter the following code into the textbox underneath

    Code:




    Mr_Osato (19/05/2009 11:39)
    And this from a company that banned ads for escorts a few months back. 'We cannot selectively discriminate' - except when we feel like it...


    Chris Morris (19/05/2009 12:11)
    I suppose the papers will now reward the BNP for their money with a story all about the row that has erupted over this. Balanced coverage please!


    Lister (19/05/2009 12:29)
    We should be eternally grateful to the hundreds of thousands of honest British people who did "selectively discriminate" and gave their lives to secure our freedom and defeat fascism. One of the strenghts of a democratic society is its ability to selectively discriminate when the need arises, not bow down to bullies and flashing pound signs. This is a new low for Newsquest. This is the bottom of the barrel.


    BarryJesus (19/05/2009 12:31)
    A newspaper can selectively discriminate against any advertiser they wish. Just like they can support any political party they wish. There is absolutley no place in my newpaper to give a party which supports racist ideas a platform.


    J (19/05/2009 12:35)
    I can see NQ argument, but Jesus, can you imagine having a big glossy BNP advert across your site. Ugly. But I suppose that's democracy though.


    J (19/05/2009 12:38)
    Just realised that my above post is illiterate, and bordering on gibberish. Note to self: edit before posting!


    Reporter (19/05/2009 13:12)
    Plunging to a new low in regional journalism. But hey look on the bright side - one advert from the BNP could pay for a few bottles of champers for the do-littles or maybe a couple of shiny alloy wheels for the Merc. Will reporters be asked to write the much-loved ad features to keep the party's cash rolling in?


    tracy (19/05/2009 13:49)
    Shock horror! To be honest I would be more outraged if I were to see an advert for Labour or Tories as they supported the bombing of Iraq; Afganistan and Serbia.


    harry oneill (19/05/2009 14:19)
    Which is more important - freedom of speech or political correctness? Should we retain the ability to publish freely, or resort to Zimbabwe style censorship? And what makes a political party whose views many people abhor acceptable rather than unaccpetable? I don't like everything the Green party (or Labour, or Conservative or Lib Dem...) propose. But does that mean they should be censored? I have felt the force of a skinhead's DM; I do not support the BNP.


    Peter (19/05/2009 17:35)
    It's an advert, that's all. To deny the BNP the right to advertise like any other party would have given them the chance to keep up the "we're just misunderstood and picked on by the mainstream media" nonsense. Yes, it looks awful as a banner ad, but so do most banner ads. As long as the editorial line doesn't change as a result, then surely the paper (and its reporters) get the best of both worlds: exposing the BNP for what it is on the editorial pages while also receiving money from the party for ads elsewhere. At the end of the day, how many of us are influenced by party adverts, especially ones from a party which is easily exposed for what it is and which consistently disappoints those who vote for it on the odd occasion it has secured a seat somewhere?


    Carl (19/05/2009 17:37)
    Could it possibly be something to do with US company Gannett desperate to suck every possible penny out of it's British subsidiary Newsquest? What next - ads for the KKK?


    Victor (19/05/2009 18:02)
    Those BNP banners are like a breath of fresh air compared to all the boring PC rubbish we constantly have to put up with. I might even start buying local papers again.


    Real World (20/05/2009 08:58)
    We live in an open society where free speach is allowed from all walks of life. If other political parties choose not to advertise in local press so be it. Everyone has the right to state their views that is what this country is about!! Get back to the real world!!


    Cathy Donahue (20/05/2009 11:40)
    It's about time the BNP wer given fair treatment to advertise as a legitimate political party. Whichver misinformd troll is saying th BNP is a racist party has already eliminated themslves from being taken seriously - basic research in to what they stand for shows this.


    E-mail this story to a friend. Your name:

    Your friend's e-mail:


    tradeclips Jobsmake the next move in your journalism career Email bulletinsget latest news and jobs directly to your desktop Freelance indexsee our searchable list for freelance help CVadd your details to our journalism talent pool Dailywho owns it? who's the editor? Weeklysearch our vast database of local titles Your Paperwhat we've written about your newspaper Your Companywhat we've written about your company Blogsbest of the UK journalism blogs Resourcescontacts, web reviews, and terms unravelled Useful Linksour guide to the major industry organisations