Page 2 of 2

"That information is blocked if editors can only report meaningless stories because vital details, however vague in order to protect identification, are missing," he said.

"Editors already have to exercise extreme caution.

"If they are restricted further they may conclude it's not worth the risk of covering the courts. That would be a tremendous threat to the principle of open justice."

The Society of Editors already contributes to the publication of guidelines for Crown Courts, which include the application of reporting restrictions. Documents have been sent out to judges and editors.

"They make it clear that restrictions such as S39 orders should be used sparingly and only if really necessary.

"The same guidelines are being put together for magistrates and are due to be published in the spring.

"It is in the interests of justice, and therefore the courts, to help editors report fairly and within the law."

Read the original story of the editors' case.

Back to the law index