The National Union of Journalists is claiming cross-party backing for its campaign against so-called ‘click targets’ for journalists.
Publisher Trinity Mirror wants to introduce the traffic targets as part of its ‘Connected Newsroom’ strategy, due to be rolled out across its regional centres over the next four months.
It will mean increased use of audience data to ensure editorial resources are focused on the most popular content.
The NUJ has raised concerns about the move and claims all four parties in the Welsh Assembly, pictured, have now pledged their support for its campaign.
The proposal is likely to mean around four job losses at TM’s Media Wales division in Cardiff, which publishes the Western Mail, South Wales Echo and website Wales Online.
Andrew RT Davies, Conservative Welsh Assembly Member, questioned the emphasis on the ‘popularity’ of stories rather than their public interest value.
“I don’t doubt that a list of celebrity fashion faux-pas would attract more clicks than a thoughtful analysis of the Welsh government’s proposals for council reorganisation – but which is more important?” he said.
“I would strongly urge Trinity Mirror to think again before pressing ahead with these plans, though they are almost certainly not the only media organisation introducing such targets.”
Labour member Ann Jones sad: “The Western Mail and other Trinity Mirror publications play a crucial role in both the scrutiny process and engaging Welsh residents with the decision making process.
“We are concerned that proposals to assess content and journalists based on the number of ‘clicks,’ will inevitably incentivise journalists to steer away from more complicated stories as well as changing the way they cover stories, potentially solely focusing on more ‘sensational’ elements.
Simon Thomas of Plaid Cymru added: “The diktat coming out of the Canary Wharf headquarters of Trinity Mirror is aimed at boosting the website clicks at Wales Online, yet it is once again cutting the workforce at Wales’s largest newspaper centre.
“Journalists must be given appropriate time to pursue and write major stories, without fear that it will be held against them because of the ‘click’ mentality.”
And the Liberal Democrats’ Peter Black said: “I’m incredibly concerned that any move towards clickbait journalism will mean less coverage for our Welsh political institutions, which can only be bad for democracy.”
“A story about someone spotting a Kim Kardashian look-alike in Gorseinon could well get more clicks than an article about underinvestment in Wrexham’s mental health services, but without more stories like the latter there will be fewer opportunities to drive forward improvements to public services.”
Martin Shipton, Media Wales journalist and chair of the NUJ’s Trinity Mirror group chapel, said: “We are grateful for the support offered to our campaign by all four parties represented in the National Assembly.
“It reflects the widespread concern that individual ‘click’ targets for journalists will lead to a race to the bottom in terms of quality.
“A sustainable future for media groups like Trinity Mirror will be determined by the level of their commitment to high quality journalism, not by a crude measure of website clicks from no matter where and no matter whom.”
Trinity Mirror has not so far responded to requests for further comment. It has previously denied that the proposals would result in more so-called “clickbait.”
Its digital publishing director has published a blog post setting out the case for the proposed changes in detail.
Much as I don’t like TM’s plans, it’s not a political issue, it’s a business one. They’ve as much right to comment on this as they have to chide Tesco for using automated tills.
Report this comment
Fat chance this will make any difference whatsoever.
Top ten nudey pics of Brtiney!!!!! here we come.
Report this comment
Let’s hope Local World journalists embrace this kind of inspired, motivational management if the mooted takeover goes ahead. Well, tough luck if they don’t really.
Report this comment
This will backfire spectacularly.
Report this comment
The most popular story on my “media comany’s” website at the weekend was “What time is X-Factor on.” A surprise winner, it edged out the Lottery results.
Report this comment
What time was X- Factor on?
Report this comment
Covered the ‘what time is’ content before – a TM bod popped up and said they are not massive traffic drivers. Do you know different Old Hack?
Prior comment: http://www.holdthefrontpage.co.uk/2015/news/circulation-falls-across-the-board-at-trinity-mirror-regionals/#comment-91549
C+P as still relevant it seems:
Carrying on from the above as am bored waiting for midnight to see what the days total stats were like.
Try some of these google searches on your fave TM title, or other newspaper titles as most are at it…..
site:liverpoolecho.co.uk “what time” OR “when is”
site:birminghammail.co.uk “what time” OR “when is”
site:dailypost.co.uk “what time” OR “when is”
site:chroniclelive.co.uk “what time” OR “when is”
site:walesonline.co.uk “what time” OR “when is”
site:coventrytelegraph.net “what time” OR “when is”
Some recent topical examples on this traffic play which appears to be run from the Liverpool hub.
http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/whats-on/film-news/wimbledon-2015-andy-murray-back-9554660
what time is andy murray back on
http://www.coventrytelegraph.net/whats-on/film-news/wimbledon-2015-andy-murray-back-9554660
what time is andy murray back on
http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/whats-on/film-news/wimbledon-2015-andy-murray-back-9554660
exact same
http://www.dailypost.co.uk/whats-on/film-news/wimbledon-2015-andy-murray-back-9554660
exact same article
http://www.walesonline.co.uk/whats-on/film-news/wimbledon-2015-andy-murray-back-9554660
exact same
similar stuff, again can be found all over the place:
http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/other-sport/tennis/andy-murrays-semi-final-against-roger-9623316
http://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/other-sport/tennis/andy-murray-playing-wimbledon-wednesday-9609661
The above works and grows traffic as people do search these terms. What is this ‘traffic growth’, and what does it mean to the metrics used to see if a website or digital property is a success?
There are other terms aside from what time / when is etc but these are just examples.
Something to ponder when the pageviews and uniques are up!
Report this comment